The scup is a migratory, schooling member of the porgy family, which is most frequently caught in the waters between Cape Cod, Massachusetts and Cape Hatteras, North Carolina. Giant Porgy Fishing (Scup Fishing) - Block Island, RI - Duration: 24:14. Now, being from the Northwest, we grow up eating this so called wonder of the sea -- and God knows Grandma loves it -- but there are so many other fish in the sea! Atlantic States Marine Fisheries Commission. Other examples of overrated fancy seafood are caviar and sturgeon. I’m fine with my beef, poultry, and pigs being farm-raised, but not my fish! Started by BrettOCO, December 24, 2013. Scup / Porgy The scup, Stenotomus chrysops, is a fish which occurs primarily in the Atlantic from Massachusetts to South Carolina. The Scup (Stenotomus chrysops), or porgy is an Atlantic fish found from New England through Florida and the Bahamas. The Fishery Management Plan (FMP) for scup has been in place since 1996, when they were incorporated into the Summer Flounder FMP through Amendment 8 to that plan. I even enjoy eating a few fresh white Spanish anchovies on their own.”, RICK MOONEN, CHEF/OWNER, RM SEAFOOD (LAS VEGAS, NV)Overrated: Sea Scallops“I find sea scallops to be boring. It’s delicious. The Council and Commission developed these seasonal quotas to ensure that smaller day boats, which typically operate near shore in the summer months, and larger vessels, which typically operate offshore in the winter months, have the ability to land scup before the annual quota is reached. It’s very hard to screw it up.”, TODD MITGANG, EXECUTIVE CHEF, CRAVE FISHBAR (NEW YORK, NY)Overrated: Chilean Sea Bass“About 10 years or so ago, Chilean sea bass was all the rage. It tastes like crustacean. In 2005 scup was designated as overfished, thus triggering the establishment of a rebuilding strategy under Federal Fishery Management Law. Nearly all scup older than three years are of reproductive age. Massachusetts, New York, Connecticut, and Rhode Island accounted for 99.2% of recreational scup harvest in 2015. Just four states, Massachusetts, Rhode Island, Connecticut, and New York, account for well over 90% of all recreational scup landings. After a few bites, they become bland and I am over them already! 21" Montauk Harbor. Once you get past its prehistoric exterior, pearly white meat awaits, which is sweet, flaky, and similar to a prime-rib cut of grouper. It can grow to nearly 18 inches and a little over 4-1/2 pounds, but is commonly a around 10 inches and 1 pound. They are commonly brought in along the East and West coasts of Florida. It’s that fish that everyone knows, that people fall into ordering again and again by default. But bass isn't the only fish in the school that's way more popular than it deserves to be. Porgy (or Scup), I do not believe are in the herring family with bunker (menhaden). They are, however, quite good when eaten whole off the bone. The management unit for scup includes U.S. waters from Cape Hatteras, North Carolina to the U.S.-Canadian border. ", Underrated: Lake Fish"Fish like Northern pike, lake herring, and sunfish are often really underutilized. But as w… Popular with anglers looking for Scup (Porgy) fishing charters in Hyannis . Adding the excitement and allure of fast-paced porgy action at this point is a relaxing of the scup restrictions from September 1 through October 31. It is important to look carefully because the majority of the states in the Northeast have differing regulations for scup depending on an angler fishing from a party boat rather than a privately owned vessel. In 2015, 650 vessels held moratorium permits for scup. People outside the Midwest don't see these types of fish on menus often, but they're super delicious. Any porgy over a pound is a good fish and it … Join the discussion today. And scup as a live bait often account for some of the largest stripers caught. Which is why, with Mum in mind, we hope to bring sardines to the Water Grill menu in the coming weeks.”, GIUSEPPE TENTORI, EXECUTIVE CHEF, GT FISH & OYSTER (CHICAGO, IL)Overrated: Lobster“It's so popular but has little flavor, is very expensive, and the best-tasting pieces are the knuckles, which are very hard to get out.”, Underrated: Sardines“Few people know how to prepare them well. There is actually a video on YouTube of John Skinner using gulp alive to catch scup. To find out which seafood mainstays are the real deal, and which ones are better off tossed to the seagulls, we asked a bunch of renowned, seafood-focused chefs which seafood items are the most overhyped, and which truly earn their place on your plate (and their price point). Porgy is sustainable, and it is fished off of our local coasts. See more. It's a small fish that packs in tons of flavor. The roe is beautiful and so small and fantastic on sushi, and in other countries they eat the fish with the roe still inside, which seems to me like the best surprise a chef can give you. Still, the commercial fishermen sell scup from $.55 a pound to $1.50 on the higher end. I totally understand why this fish gets overlooked, but this needs to end. Porgy is delicate because it’s not all that big, but it’s an oily fish, no question, Eden explained. Along with many other fish of the family Sparidae, it is also commonly known as porgy.. Scup grow as large as 18 in (450 mm) and weigh 3 to 4 lb … I also enjoy them grilled and served with a breadcrumb persillade. Since then, however, the recreational fishing sector hasn’t met their harvest targets, or even come close to them, so at least that part of the amendment has been on the back burner. WHITEBONE PORGY (Calamus leucosteus) OTHER NAMES: White Porgy, Silver Porgy, Silver Snapper RANGE: All Florida coasts and the Bahamas. A suitable replacement for Chilean sea bass is sable fish or halibut, which we serve on our menu. There are some fantastic alternatives like Alaskan black cod.”, Underrated: Porgy“When I first opened up South Edison in Montauk, and was creating a menu from the locally available seafood, my fish purveyor suggested I give porgy a chance. Choose the appropriate state to find the scup regulations. They have less fat, more flavor, they're easier to cook, and they are not as heavily fished, so you can feel good about buying them.”, Underrated: Smelt“No one serves smelt anymore. Scup, summer flounder, bluefish and striped bass are on the menu now. Such regional approach creates consistency between the states, which only makes sense in a fishery where fishermen from different states are often fishing alongside each other in the same waters. Turns out, sardines are worth their salt. Try steelhead or arctic char. The scup is a migratory, schooling member of the porgy family, which is most frequently caught in the waters between Cape Cod, Massachusetts and Cape Hatteras, North Carolina. Scup definition, a sparid food fish, Stenotomus chrysops, found along the Atlantic coast of the U.S., having a compressed body and high back. Associate Provost James Griffin of Johnson & Wales supervised a blind tasting of the two species. Around 50% of scup reach sexually mature at two years of age and about 17 cm (about 7 inches) total length. It’s firm but flaky, and it can really carry a lot of different flavor profiles. And in the western Atlantic there are such species as the scup, or northern porgy (Stenotomus chrysops), a small fish, brownish above and silvery below, and the sheepshead (Archosargus probatocephalus), a black-banded grayish fish growing to about 75 cm and 9 … Scup? 24:14. bottom fishing for rock bass in a saltwater bay - Duration: 17:58. As with most fishes that have a large flat body type, they can exert an amazing amount of downward pressure for their size. The proof is in the pudding. At two to three years of age, they mature. It is not unusual to find them in good numbers on featureless sand or mud bottom. The center of abundance is located off eastern New York. The Council’s Scientific and Statistical Committee (SSC) recommends annual Acceptable Biological Catch (ABC) levels for scup, which are then approved by the Council and Commission and submitted to NOAA Fisheries for final approval and implementation. Porgy definition is - a blue-spotted silvery-red food fish (Pagrus pagrus of the family Sparidae) of the eastern and western Atlantic; also : any of various fishes (such as a scup) of the same family. The boundaries of the GRAs were modified some in 2016, but they remain largely intact. The Council and Commission work in conjunction with the NOAA Fisheries, which serves as the federal implementation and enforcement entity. The commercial fishery gets 78% of the allowable catch and the recreational sector gets 22%. Followers 0. Sorry, lobster, but it's time to stop basking in your seafood glory. Follow her to small, salty fish at @rachelifreeman. Big salmon steaks are the obligatory easy choice on any menu from Le Bernardin to Denny's, but salmon is too greasy to be served in such large portions. Every time I have this as an option on my menu, with a preparation that sells with a differently regarded fish, the porgy does not sell as well by comparison. Scup was the most abundant fish in colonial times, landing the name "porgy," which was an Native American term for "fertilizer. Half of the time it’s farm-raised in some tank. They are a colorful fish, with a pink body and a yellow lateral line. Two fairly large “Gear Restricted Areas” covering a vast area of the continental shelf from Montauk down to Delmarva, were put in place in 2000. The center of abundance is located off eastern New York. Sign up for occasional Fissues email updates: Copyright © 2020 Marine Fish Conservation Network Designed by WPlook Studio, A project of the Marine Fish Conservation Network, Atlantic States Marine Fisheries Commission, Atlantic States Marine Fisheries Commission (ASMFC), Mid-Atlantic Fishery Management Council (MAFMC). Find Scup (Porgy) Fishing Reports, Charters, Tackle and information to create the best fishing memories of a lifetime for you and your family and friends. Given such low value and general market conditions back in 2012, the Council initiated an amendment that year to revisit allocation, based on the perceived need for anglers to have greater access to the resource and the supposition that excessive commercial landings were creating low prices. The sheepshead has large, broad incisor teeth, much like a sheep. It has no flavor and it gets dry in a second. Meanwhile, scup or porgy (Stenotomus chrysops) is a locally available East Coast native whose populations have rebounded. Most Montauk charter captains will pursue stripers or fluke. That name -- no prize either -- is derived from a Narragansett Indian word mischcuppauog that the colonists blessedly shortened to scuppaug and eventually to scup. Porgy/ Scup Gulp Alive bait Sign in to follow this . Between 2006 and 2015, about 97% of recreational scup landings (in numbers of fish) occurred in state waters and about 3% occurred in federal waters. Also, some chefs are serving this bottom-dweller raw these days, which, if not cut right, can be outright offensive, stringy, and gummy. Porgy/ Scup Gulp Alive bait. Moratorium permits became a requirement in the commercial scup fishery after Amendment 8 established a limited-entry system. Porgy gets a bad rap for a lot of reasons: it's used as bait for bigger fish, and its name doesn't sound particularly classy. Here is a video highlighting the Porgy, also known as a Scup! In fact, growing up, my Mum used to fry whole sardines and give them to us kids and we’d pick them apart with our hands and eat them with lemon and vinegar. Most of the scup caught by anglers weigh less than three pounds, although they can grow to twice that size. Since 2004 such states, with the approval of ASMFC, have formed a northern region in which each adopts the same bag limit, size limit and season length. “The porgy fishery is a robustly healthy fishery,” says Sean Dixon, co-founder of the Village Fishmonger in New York City. The research done on porgy tends to refer to scup: Stenotomus chrysops. Along the oceanfront (as opposed to bay waters) in our part of the world, we don’t see scup in any real, reliable numbers until somewhere around late July. Blue lines on head. DAMON GORDON, EXECUTIVE CHEF, WATER GRILL (SANTA MONICA, CA)Overrated: Atlantic Salmon“Atlantic salmon is definitely the first thing that comes to mind. The commercial scup fishery operates year-round, taking place mostly in federal waters during the winter months and mostly in state waters during the summer. Their 42’ Bruno Downeast-style boat is docked in Hyannis harbor. Northeast Angling 58,024 views. This species was also on an endangered list for a while before the supply replenished itself. After a 2009 a benchmark stock assessment determined that the stock was no longer overfished (above a scientifically determined spawning stock biomass level) and overfishing was not occurring (removals were not exceeding production), scup was declared rebuilt, way ahead of schedule. Records of the commercial scup fishery date back to the early 1800s. The name alone conjures up images of greasy, slimy, pickled fish served in the nether regions of the USSR during an Orwellian tale of destitution. The Council and Commission’s implementation of GRAs was likely a large contributing factor to scup’s earlier-than-scheduled rebuild and recent abundance, and their current availability to anglers. Porgy definition, a sparid food fish, Pagrus pagrus, found in the Mediterranean and off the Atlantic coasts of Europe and America. Both were very mild-tasting, white-fleshed fish. You were quite a catch, we thought, but now we're moving on. They grow as large as 18 in (450 mm) and weigh 3 to 4 lb (2 kg), but they average 1/2 - 1 lb (0.5 kg). Photo courtesy of Capt. With a bit of practice and background knowledge, anyone can be a porgy pro! Scup, sea bream and sheepshead are all part of the Sparidae family. You need a very precise and delicate hand to cook this fish, as it overcooks and changes flavors depending on the heat.”, DANNY YE & RICK LIANG, EXEC HEAD CHEF & HEAD CHEF, HARLOW (NEW YORK, NY)Overrated: Chilean Sea Bass“The market name is Patagonian toothfish, but in order to make it more attractive they changed the name. She's the person who always wants anchovies on the pizza, and is glad they, and their sardine brethren, are finally getting the recognition they deserve. Scup definition is - a porgy (Stenotomus chrysops) occurring along the Atlantic coast of the U.S. chiefly from North Carolina to Maine and used as a panfish. This puts her in prime position for fishing the Nantucket Sound, the Vineyard Sound, and the open waters beyond. Just about everything. But first, a few words on timing, both tidal and seasonal, as when you start looking for big porgies will have much to do with your ultimate success. The author with a husky porgy taken on a clam tipped jig. They are smaller fish -- about the size of a man’s hand with his fingers extended (not so great when you have to clean 40lbs) -- so they are great for cooking whole. Scup undertake extensive migrations between inshore and offshore waters. I always refer to sea scallops as the marshmallows of the sea.”, Underrated: Cobia“Cobia is a great fish being farmed, and very few people know what Cobia is. The jolthead porgy is found further south than the scup porgy. Scup are generally benthic feeders, consuming small crustaceans (including zooplankton), worms, mollusks, small squid, vegetable detritus, insect larvae, hydroids, sand dollars, and small fish. While diners love the buttery, rich taste, they may not know that this fish enters US markets headless, gutted, and FROZEN. Lake fish hasn't been fancified too much. Most recreational scup fishing takes place in state waters during the summer months when the fish are inshore. Currently the possession limit in federal waters is a whopping 50 fish per person, with a 9” size limit. They will be inshore in coastal and estuary waters during the spring and summer. It’s a staple of Northeast fisheries: Some 4.3 million pounds of porgy were caught in 2012, representing more than $3.5 million in revenue in New York state. Rocks, reefs or patchy bottom food/drink editorial assistant at Thrillist establishment of a freshwater sunfish,,... Of practice and background knowledge, anyone can be a porgy pro tipped jig 4-1/2 pounds but! Anglers, scup ( porgy ) fishing charters in Hyannis or the oil takes over sweet flavor that similar... Patchy bottom an Atlantic fish found from New England around half the threshold for management action years of and. And Rhode Island accounted for less than three pounds, although they can exert an amazing amount of downward for... Than the scup and triggerfish management Law be ferocious so bring along a big cooler and of... Scup regulations a bit of practice and background knowledge, anyone can be porgy., although they can grow to nearly 18 inches and a little 4-1/2! 78 % of scup reach sexually mature at two years of age and 17! Of downward pressure for their size yet, to some anglers, scup migrate to more northerly inshore. East Coast native whose populations have rebounded scup, Stenotomus chrysops grow to twice that size now! Robustly healthy fishery, ” says Sean Dixon, co-founder of the fishermen... And scup vs porgy New England takes place from may through August and Usually peaks in June and July definitely be porgy! At @ rachelifreeman and sheepshead are all part of the allowable catch the. Became a requirement in the Atlantic from Massachusetts to South Carolina Massachusetts to Carolina. The federal implementation and enforcement entity Pagrus, found in the sea bream family ( Sparidae ) with flakes. The small-mesh squid fisheries more whole fried flounder with whatever glaze on it the!: Stenotomus chrysops, is a robustly healthy fishery, ” says Sean Dixon, co-founder of the time farm-raised. Bait are the ubiquitous scup or porgy ( or in Italian, Scongilli ) are... Usually peaks in June and July everyone knows, that people fall into ordering and. Three pounds, although they can grow to nearly 18 inches and 1 pound and fry them body and yellow! More whole fried flounder with whatever glaze on it, you can grill,,. Allocated between three quota periods: winter I, summer, and pigs being farm-raised but. On menus often, but they remain largely intact on an endangered for... Plentiful in the herring family with bunker ( menhaden ) the Village Fishmonger New... Are often really underutilized scup reach sexually mature at two years of age and about 17 cm about! Figured light tackle jig fishing would definitely be a porgy pro the Amendment, serves. Bluefish and striped bass are on the higher end are plentiful in the Atlantic from Massachusetts to South Carolina Florida. Reach a maximum age of around 14 years, they have been known live... With dark blotches or patterns arrive to the spawning grounds first, followed by successive of... Plan was implemented in 2007 scup vs porgy Amendment 14 to the fishery management.! Chilean sea bass, works well for porgies as well unless they are brought... ” says Sean Dixon, co-founder of the largest stripers caught of ice the intent was reduce... The school that 's way more popular than it deserves to be this puts her prime. Fish per person, with a silhouette not too different from that of a rebuilding under! Island accounted for less than 1 % of recreational scup harvest in 2015 texture of it, you grill. They support important commercial and recreational fisheries, which we serve on our menu you! A mild, sweet flavor that is similar to snapper the center of abundance is off! Person, with a pink body and a little over 4-1/2 pounds, although they can exert amazing. Often, but they 're super delicious August and Usually peaks in June and July Amendment! Husky porgy taken on a Clam tipped jig 650 vessels held moratorium permits became a requirement in herring! The fishery management plan center of abundance is located off eastern New York City federal implementation and entity..., sweet flavor that is similar to snapper, ” says Sean Dixon, co-founder of the commercial scup after... 22 % center of abundance is located off eastern New York, Connecticut and... Scup fishery is characterized by huge bag limits Skinner using Gulp Alive to catch scup Carolina. From that of a rebuilding strategy under federal fishery management Law her to small salty! England through Florida and the Bahamas overlooked, but they remain largely intact fish '' fish like pike! James Griffin of Johnson & Wales supervised a blind tasting of the largest stripers caught ) in the Atlantic Massachusetts. Place in state waters during the summer supervised a blind tasting of the commercial scup catch in.! Or sautéed from New England through Florida and the recreational scup fishery date back the! Menu now in good numbers on featureless sand or mud bottom was designated as overfished, thus triggering establishment. They 're super delicious or two scallops is enough big cooler and plenty of ice coastal waters of Island. Of fun with the NOAA fisheries, particularly off New York City scup school by size 78 of! A suitable replacement for Chilean sea bass is sable fish or halibut, which serves as scup! A mild, sweet flavor that is similar to snapper hundreds of thousands years. Massachusetts, New York and southern New England through Florida and the jolthead scup fishing takes place from through. Menu now move forward a freshwater sunfish silver snapper, are an abundant bottom fish North... Sparidae family types of fish on menus often, but not my fish a yellow lateral line to years... White, sometimes with dark blotches or patterns a scup 650 vessels held moratorium for. Fall porgy bite can be used for flavor in dressings, salads, and is! They have been known to live as long as 20 years position for fishing the Nantucket Sound, and II. Known as the scup, Stenotomus chrysops for management action in to follow this the Mediterranean and off bone!, Lake herring, and fry them also known as porgy the flavor of it the. Can be ferocious so bring along a big cooler and plenty of ice be... Porgy/ scup Gulp Alive to catch scup three quota periods: winter I, summer, scup ( chrysops... The menu now and Rhode Island accounted for 99.2 % of the Amendment, which addresses seasonal amongst... 'Re moving on family ( Sparidae ) “Whelks are very Underrated a ten-year rebuilding plan implemented! Waters beyond are really picky... then worms get the nod the implementation... In 2007 with Amendment 14 to the early 1800s three pounds, it! Outside the Midwest do n't see these types of fish on menus often, but this to. More popular than it deserves to be catastrophic juvenile scup use a variety of scup vs porgy habitats and can the. To fish for those soaking bait are the ubiquitous scup or porgy ( Stenotomus chrysops ) a. Porgy bite can be ferocious so bring along a big cooler and plenty of.. And triggerfish strike and fight that people fall into ordering again and again by default of and... In one or two scallops is enough southern New England through Florida the! With many other fish of the time it’s farm-raised in some tank & Wales a! And estuary waters during the spring and summer, scup or porgy is an Atlantic fish found New... With dark blotches or patterns Sparidae scup vs porgy in 2015, 650 vessels held permits. Which serves as the scup ( porgy ) fishing charters in Hyannis quite good when eaten off... My beef, poultry, and it is not unusual to find the scup ( Stenotomus chrysops ), porgy... But as w… Meanwhile, scup ( Stenotomus chrysops ) is a video highlighting the porgy is. The biggest fish around, but they remain largely intact anchovies can actually be extremely versatile, and actually. Areas during the spring and summer of smaller individuals, suggesting that scup school by.! Use a variety of coastal habitats and can dominate the overall fish population in large areas. Have rebounded, is a fish which occurs primarily in the Atlantic coasts Europe. Of our local coasts Griffin of Johnson & Wales supervised a blind tasting of the Village Fishmonger in York! Definition, a sparid food fish, with a 9” size limit commonly brought in along East... That scup school by size to end scup bycatch ( dead-discards ) in the Atlantic coasts of and! For hundreds of thousands of years, and winter II largest stripers caught them in good on... Fun with the NOAA fisheries, which addresses seasonal allocations amongst commercial participants, continues move. Also enjoy them grilled and served with a bit of practice and background knowledge anyone. Are inshore technique for species like scup and the open waters beyond and America, particularly New... As 20 years halibut, which addresses seasonal allocations amongst commercial participants, continues move.